| Division 4 | Thu 1 Oct 2015 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Matthew Williams (Abbeydale 3) | 10-15, 11-15, 7-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 28 Jan 2016 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Mark Ross (Hallamshire 6) | 12-15, 8-15, 15-11, 8-15 | | 1-3 |
| Cup D | Thu 4 Feb 2016 | #4 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Dave Bates (C & R Health 2) | 10-15, 3-15, 11-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Fri 17 Mar 2017 | #3 | Ben Losel (Fulwood 5) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-10, 15-8, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 16 Nov 2017 | #4 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Ryan Marsden (Woodfield 4) | 12-15, 6-15, 12-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 1 Feb 2018 | #4 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Ryan Marr (Woodfield 5) | 15-5, 15-3, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 29 Mar 2018 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Richard Hobson (Phoenix 1) | 12-15, 15-10, 12-15, 5-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 31 Jan 2019 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | James McClure (Sheffield Medics) | 10-15, 17-15, 11-15, 10-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 7 Feb 2019 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Jason Salf (Rotherham) | 15-4, 15-5, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Fri 15 Feb 2019 | #3 | Colin Watson (Woodfield 7) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-9, 13-15, 6-15, 13-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 21 Feb 2019 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Alex Timmins-Jones (Woodfield 8) | 10-15, 14-16, 10-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 28 Feb 2019 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Tom Jackson (Hallamshire 5) | 15-6, 14-16, 15-17, 11-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 2 | Sun 17 Mar 2019 | #4 | Tom Murton (Hallamshire 3) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 3) | 15-2, 15-12, 15-6 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Sun 31 Mar 2019 | #3 | Ross Galbraith (Hallamshire 6) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 10-15, 10-15, 8-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Tue 17 Sep 2019 | #3 | Al Jennings (Phoenix 3) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 13-15, 0-15, 7-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 26 Sep 2019 | #1 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Jim Muirhead (Hallamshire 6) | 9-15, 8-15, 9-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Mon 7 Oct 2019 | #3 | Josh Underhill (Queens Park) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-8, 15-5, 11-15, 15-10 | | 3-1 |
| Division 4 | Sun 13 Oct 2019 | #3 | Elliot Boardwell (Hallamshire 8) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-12, 5-15, 3-15, 8-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 21 Nov 2019 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Tony Illidge (Woodfield 7) | 15-8, 15-9, 15-12 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Thu 5 Dec 2019 | #1 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Tristan Slaney (Sheffield Medics) | 6-15, 13-15, 11-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 12 Dec 2019 | #2 | Dan Milner (Stocksbridge) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 6-15, 13-15, 13-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 23 Jan 2020 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Rameez Ibrahim (Hallamshire 7) | 9-15, 15-13, 12-15, 10-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 6 Feb 2020 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Fergus Hunt (Hallamshire 8) | 15-13, 15-6, 9-15, 15-11 | | 3-1 |
| Division 4 | Sun 23 Feb 2020 | #2 | Andy Hogg (Hallamshire 6) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-12, 15-5, 15-13 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Wed 11 Mar 2020 | #1 | Tristan Slaney (Sheffield Medics) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 16-14, 15-9, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Thu 14 Oct 2021 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Tom medics (Sheffield Medics) | 12-15, 12-15, 16-14, 15-8, 11-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 4 | Tue 2 Nov 2021 | #2 | Phil Mellor (Doncaster 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 9-15, 12-15, 15-9, 12-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Wed 10 Nov 2021 | #2 | Carl Sherwood (Phoenix 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-6, 15-6, 8-15, 15-7 | | 3-1 |
| Division 4 | Wed 17 Nov 2021 | #2 | Adam Flinders (Sheffield Medics) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 12-15, 6-15, 14-16 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 28 Nov 2021 | #3 | Amen Ali (Hallamshire 7) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 4-15, 12-15, 13-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 9 Dec 2021 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Alex Timmins-Jones (Stocksbridge) | 15-12, 10-15, 12-15, 8-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 6 Jan 2022 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Mark Morrison (Doncaster 2) | 15-12, 15-5, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Thu 3 Feb 2022 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Alex Hurdley (Phoenix 2) | 15-2, 15-3, 15-4 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Thu 17 Feb 2022 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Edward Green (Fulwood 5) | 17-19, 15-11, 9-15, 15-13, 13-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 22 Sep 2022 | #1 | Ed Walker (Stocksbridge) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-0, 15-3, 15-3 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Mon 3 Oct 2022 | #3 | Chris Cartwright (Barnsley 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 12-15, 15-8, 15-5, 16-14 | | 3-1 |
| Division 3 | Sun 23 Oct 2022 | #4 | Mayan Salehi (Hallamshire 5) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-7, 2-15, 11-15, 3-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 6 Nov 2022 | #3 | Richard Louden (Hallamshire 4) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 10-15, 10-15, 12-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 24 Nov 2022 | #3 | Paul Gane (Woodfield 3) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-10, 15-8, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 5 Jan 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Adam Bierton (Hallamshire 5) | 10-15, 7-15, 15-5, 15-10, 15-8 | | 3-2 |
| Division 3 | Thu 19 Jan 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Ian Broomhead (Barnsley 2) | 15-11, 15-6, 15-5 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 2 Feb 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Richard Louden (Hallamshire 4) | 15-12, 10-15, 15-11, 15-10 | | 3-1 |
| Division 3 | Thu 2 Mar 2023 | #3 | Phil Mason (Woodfield 4) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 12-15, 8-15, 13-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 10 Sep 2023 | #3 | Luke Cottingham (Hallamshire 5) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-5, 15-8, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 21 Sep 2023 | #2 | Alex Timmins-Jones (Stocksbridge) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-13, 15-13, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Mon 9 Oct 2023 | #3 | Simon Clarke (Barnsley 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-4, 15-5, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Vets | Tue 17 Oct 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale Vets) | V | Chris Cartwright (Barnsley Vets) | 15-8, 10-15, 10-15, 13-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 19 Oct 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Josh Gibling (Hallamshire 6) | 15-11, 15-11, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Vets | Mon 30 Oct 2023 | #2 | Paul Robinson (Woodfield Vets) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale Vets) | 7-15, 13-15, 8-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 5 Nov 2023 | #3 | Glyn Williams (Hallamshire 6) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 7-15, 8-15, 8-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Fri 10 Nov 2023 | #3 | Gary Ward (Doncaster 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-12, 15-6, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 16 Nov 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Martin Lilley (Woodfield 2) | 7-15, 15-9, 18-16, 15-13 | | 3-1 |
| Vets | Tue 5 Dec 2023 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale Vets) | V | Neil Soloman (Hallamshire Vets) | 15-13, 15-8, 15-17, 15-10 | | 3-1 |
| Division 3 | Thu 7 Dec 2023 | #2 | Adam Cattell (Woodfield 3) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-13, 15-8, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Vets | Tue 16 Jan 2024 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale Vets) | V | Nij Precious (Woodfield Vets) | 15-9, 15-8, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 18 Jan 2024 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Mark Morrison (Doncaster 2) | 5-15, 11-15, 15-7, 9-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 25 Jan 2024 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Jim Uttley (Barnsley 2) | 3-15, 4-15, 9-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 1 Feb 2024 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Mark Wingfield (Stocksbridge) | 15-11, 15-11, 15-5 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 22 Feb 2024 | #3 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Edward Barnes (Hallamshire 5) | 15-13, 15-10, 16-14 | | 3-0 |
| Vets | Thu 7 Mar 2024 | #2 | Mark Beynon (Barnsley Vets) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale Vets) | 15-7, 15-12, 15-11 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 7 Mar 2024 | #2 | Mike Parker (Woodfield 2) | V | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | 15-11, 15-9, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 21 Mar 2024 | #2 | Paul Garbett (Abbeydale 4) | V | Rob Waller (Woodfield 3) | 15-5, 11-15, 10-15, 11-15 | | 1-3 |
